VST News : Summer 2006
MEET OUR PEOPLE!
It's five years since we started Network Theni and in that time your donations have touched the lives of thousands of people. Let us introduce you to some of them.
Meet Vijaya, the president of a federation of women's groups who never thought she would see so much change for the better in her life.
Or Vinotha who was in such despair she was thinking of killing her baby daughter. Or Padma, whose brickmaking business is thriving with a Network Theni loan.
The experiences of these people and five others are described in this newsletter along with an account of what we've achieved under Network Theni and where we go next.
Federation leader
Before I became involved in the women's self-help group movement I knew nothing about the outside world. When SRED (one the Network Theni NGOs) established self-help groups in my area in 1998, they sent me on a new journey in life. First they gave us training on how to manage a self-help group, how to overcome problems, how to access government programmes. Then they educated us about gender and our rights as women. All these ideas were new to us. I developed leadership skills and became the president of my self-help group and then I was elected as president of the women's federation.
I was asked to attend training on Panchayat Raj institutions and my self-help group encouraged me to stand for election. I told them that I was illiterate and that I couldn't do such a thing. But SRED said that education wasn't needed, I just needed to be able to speak and make my point heard. But the men in my village disagreed they asked us what we thought we were doing. SRED spent three months in the area attending village meetings and organising public programmes to educate voters. Eventually the men agreed to allow me to stand and I was elected.
My Panchayat (village council) has made many improvements over the last five years. We've built roads and installed street lighting. We've built a village threshing platform. We reclaimed village land from a rich man who had bribed government officials to take ownership of it. We are going to use this land to build government houses for the families that don't have their own homes.
I have grown a lot since becoming president of the federation and a Panchayat ward member. I've gained confidence in my own life. I'd never have thought that I could learn so many things and see so much change for the better at this point in my life.
The desperate mother
Vinotha and her husband are both agricultural labourers
from very poor families. After the birth of their second
daughter they worried that they could not afford to educate
two daughters let alone be able to pay any dowry for them,
which would mean they would remain unmarried. A village
health committee member was informed that Vinotha and her husband were thinking of killing their
newborn daughter.
The committee visited the family at home and promised that they would find them financial help to stop them committing female infanticide. They told Vinotha about government schemes that have been set up to help families with daughters. The committee, with the help of MMS (a Network Theni NGO), applied for and secured 15,000 rupees each for both children. The money is held in the girls' names at the Post Office and will mature in five years when it will be worth 21,000 rupees.
Vinotha has been given counselling and has now been sterilised. She still worries about how she will be able to look after two growing children.
Entrepreneur
Eight years ago my husband and I started our brick making
business. Before that we used to work for other people
making bricks. Three years ago I applied to borrow 15,000
rupees from the federation through my self-help group.
Members from the federation and Arogya Agam (a Network
Theni NGO) came to inspect the business and agreed to
lend the money. I used the money to pay off an outstanding
loan from money lenders that was at a very high interest and
was eating all our profit. Since then we have been able to
grow the business.
We have now paid back the first loan from the federation and we have applied and been accepted for a second loan of 25,000 rupees. With this money we will be able to expand the business even more. We currently employ five people, and will employ more when we get bigger. Brick making is physically hard and tiring work, but it is reliable and there is good money to be made.
The loans from the federation have saved us from the money lenders and allowed us to make our business successful. My husband also respects me and treats me as an equal because I have been able to secure the loans for our business.
Seeker of justice
My ten-year-old daughter had become quiet and withdrawn.
Eventually she told me that she had been sexually assaulted
by a man from the village. He is a married man in his late
twenties and has a bad reputation around here. My daughter
hadn't told me immediately because this man was
threatening to kill her if she told anyone what had happened.
I went to the village elders, but none of them were interested. They told me not to get outsiders involved and that they would settle the matter themselves by sending the man out of the village. They told me to keep it quiet and not to make a fuss, otherwise I would bring shame upon my daughter. I was angry about their attitude so I went to SRED who were very concerned. Along with Arogya Agam and SRED, I went to the police station with my family to report the incident. My daughter was medically examined and the police charged the man with rape. He is now in jail and we are waiting for the trial. SRED have been very supportive, given me lots of advice and are covering our legal costs, as we don't have that sort of money.
My immediate community and self-help group are supporting me. I've been to the police station a number of times on my own. As a family we will face whatever we have to. Just yesterday my daughter went to the temple to celebrate a festival. The priest wouldn't let her enter and sent her away. I went to ask him why and he told me that the gods were angry with her and my family for getting the police involved.
Since the man was arrested other families have told me about incidents involving this man, but they were too afraid to speak out.
President, sex worker network
I have two daughters aged 19 and 16. My eldest has learning
difficulties. My husband left me 10 years ago. I used to work
as a labourer in construction, but as a single woman from a
low caste, I had to have sex with the engineer, the mason, the
contractor and even the owner just to get the work, which is
very badly paid. When some women told me that I could
earn more money from prostitution I thought it couldn't be
any worse than my current situation.
Arogya Agam encouraged me to join the Women in Prostitution Network. I am now the president of the network. It's called Pudumai Pengal Cuttamaipu, which means ‘New Women's Federation'. This year on International Women's Day I was asked to speak at a public meeting about the work we do. We raise awareness of our basic rights, especially concerning the law, and help women who have been arrested with emotional and legal support. For example, last month five sex workers were arrested and put in jail. I helped to arrange their bail and give them legal advice. Before the network, we would never have helped each other out. We also encourage women to insist on using condoms to prevent HIV and other STDs.
Three months ago I visited another federation for women sex workers in a nearby district. We talked about our problems and I learnt more about our rights. We discussed how we must begin to fight for justice and the legalisation of prostitution. By working together we will become stronger.
Before I joined the network the police would come to the lodge where I worked and demand free sex, and if I didn't agree they would fabricate cases against me. Now they know that I am president of the network they do not bother me any more.
Living with HIV
My husband died four years ago. He caught TB but didn't
take the drugs properly so he became resistant to the
antibiotics and died. After he died I kept getting ill with fever
and other diseases. Parvathi, the health guide in my village,
kept telling me to go for an HIV test but I was too scared. I
didn't want to die like my husband. Eventually I let her take me to Arogya Agam for a test. When they found
out I was positive they took me to the big government medical college nearby where they put me on antiretroviral
therapy. I have been taking ART for eight months now, I am feeling much stronger and I don't get
ill any more.
I have a nine-year-old son who is HIV negative. Because I am not physically strong enough to work in the fields, Arogya Agam provide money for my son's education as well as school books and a uniform.
I am also a member of Theni District Network for Positive People. They visit me in my home and talk to me about my illness. Through them I meet other people who are HIV positive and go to training sessions on how to look after my health. I now feel more confident about my life and I am determined to stay healthy so I can look after my son. If it wasn't for Parvathi I would be dead by now, and I thank her for saving my life every time I see her in the street.
Dalit activist
I am lucky enough to have attended school until I was 15
unlike my father who didn't go to school and keeps cattle for
higher caste people. However, as I was growing up I noticed
how I was treated differently from my school friends. In a tea
shop I wasn't allowed to sit on a chair or drink from the same
cup as my friends. I wasn't allowed to wear shoes in the
street. I hated being treated like this. I knew I didn't want to
live such a life so I left my village and went to work in a textile
mill in a nearby town.
When I had earned enough money to buy some land and build a house I returned to my village. I thought people would treat me differently once I had my own house, but they didn't. I had purchased some expensive shoes and people used to tell me to stop wearing them because of my caste. But I ignored them and carried on wearing my shoes. Things have changed over the last few years since the government brought in new laws against untouchability and my people have started to gain more confidence. But there is still much work to do. The higher caste people still believe deep down that they are better than us even if they don't always show it on the outside.
From next month I will be working at Arogya Agam as an outreach worker. I will visit the Arunthidiyar community in the villages and tell them about my experiences and encourage them to stand up for their rights so they can make their lives better.
Village health guide
Arogya Agam came to my village and asked for a volunteer
to train as a village health guide. I wanted to help people in
my village so I stepped forward. I ensure TB patients take all
their medicine so that they do not become resistant to the
antibiotic. I work with HIV patients to make sure they stay
healthy and get the right medicine. I also specialise in youth
development and mother and child health. I sell condoms
from my front room.
It makes me happy when I see the direct influence I am able to have in people's lives. I managed to stop a case of female infanticide by convincing the family to keep the child. I also persuaded a young widow nearby to take an HIV test after her husband fell ill and died. At first she was reluctant to look after her health when she discovered she was HIV positive. I have counselled her about her illness and now that she is getting antiretroviral treatment she is becoming healthy again. When I see her on the street she thanks me for saving her life. I also helped a young couple who both had an STD. They had spent a lot of money on treatments but nothing had worked. Government hospitals don't help because they discriminate against people with STDs. I took them to Arogya Agam where they were treated for gonorrhoea. They were cured and since then they have had their first child.
Now if anyone in the village is ill they come to me first for help. Before they would have gone to pray at the temple or paid a local indigenous ‘doctor' for expensive medicines.
Arogya Agam pays me 700 rupees a month for the work I do.
THE RECKONING
Tony Huckle assesses five yers of Network TheniThe idea was to make an impact. Focus on women and Dalits, the most disadvantaged. Bring a group of NGOs together in one locality to work on TB, Aids, women's rights, small-scale enterprise, and use the local political system to benefit the poor. Create and work with women's self-help groups. That was the grand plan when we started Network Theni five years ago. So did it work?
173,387 people helped
in 543 villages
17,551 women enrolled in self-help groups
2,314 treated for TB
60,527 educated about HIV/Aids
92,995 mothers' and children's health benefited
Of course Aids and TB and poverty and discrimination have not vanished overnight. But in the accounts of the eight people featured in this newsletter you can sense a society on the move. Things have changed. More and more people know about Aids and TB: how to recognise these diseases, how they can be treated. Thousands of women have exchanged laborious badly paid farm work for theirown small enterprises. Women in villages across Theni district now stand up for their rights, refuse to accept a second class existence and fulfil their potential. Politics and community life is changing from one dominated by men and wealth and shady practices to one that is open and fair to all.
We set some targets for what we wanted to achieve, and now we can call up the results.
- In TB we exceeded our target of curing 2,040 patients, and after some early technical teething troubles we beat the WHO's benchmark for cure rates. In the first years we concentrated on survey work to find TB sufferers; later as knowledge about TB spread we could rely on people with symptoms such as persistent cough to present themselves for treatment. Our TB programme was accepted as part of the government's national TB control programme and we benefited from free government TB drugs. More recently the focus of TB work switched from providing treatment ourselves to referring patients to the government primary health centres for treatment.
- In Aids we aimed to reach 45,000 people at particular risk; we actually reached more than 60,000. At first we focused on educating people about Aids and promoting safer sex through street theatre and mass awareness campaigns. Later we concentrated on trying to persuade particular high risk groups such as sex workers and truck drivers to change their behaviour. One particularly effective strategy was to train young men as ‘peer educators' to spread the message among their associates. We also formed self-help groups among sex workers. It soon became apparent that sexually transmitted infections contributed to transmission of the HIV virus so we set up STI clinics, treating large numbers and their partners. STI levels have fallen in the areas where we work.
- In mother and child health we planned on working with 85,700 beneficiaries. We estimate almost 93,000 benefited. At first we concentrated on recruiting and training village health workers but from the second year switched emphasis to one of cooperation with government primary health centres, encouraging people to use their services and supporting the PHC staff. As a result severe malnourishment, vitamin deficiency and childhood diseases such as measles have become rare. Better maternity services have reduced birth complications and infant mortality.
- In micro-enterprise we expected 8,000 women would start their own businesses. It turned out 10,523 did so. Network Theni mobilised 145 million rupees (just under £2m) in credit and subsidies to finance small businesses. Half of this came from the savings of self-help group members; the rest from our own revolving funds and bank loans. This credit, more than any other factor, lifted women's position in society. It freed them from moneylenders, gave them better incomes, made them less dependent on men, improved their self-esteem and status. Many invested their loans in land, animals, shops, housing and children's education. More recently there have been attempts to diversify into non-traditional enterprises.
- Violence against women. This is not easy to quantify. But in each year of the programme we took up more and more issues such as sexual and dowry harassment, female infanticide and domestic violence. In the last year almost 800 cases were documented. There is a clear indication that people no longer readily resort to violence for fear of action by the women or police. Studies have shown a decline in infanticide.
- Panchayat Raj. Our aim was to make the elected village councils work for the benefit of the poor. These were new institutions with the first elections in 2001. We worked to get women elected, and with women presidents to make them more effective. At first none of the 37 women presidents could function well alone. Now almost half can and most of the others are making good progress. We used village meetings to make the voice of the disadvantaged heard. In the last year alone across 42 panchayats benefits to Dalits included 404 new houses, 605 house maintenance schemes, 395 electrifications, 38 roads, 967 toilets, 26 water supplies, 16 threshing floors, 40 drainage schemes, 511 new ration cards (for subsidised food) and 10 burial grounds.
£948,094 Total cost
£255,979 from Big Lottery Fund
£165,398 from Department for International Development
£112,080 from Elton John Aids Foundation /Rufford Foundation
£80,000 from Target TB
£130,133 from other trusts
£204,504 from individuals and groups
In many ways it is not so much in these statistics, but in the people that we can see real change. Most impressive of all are the people's organisations Network Theni has brought about; the village selfhelp groups and their federations, the positive people's association, the sex worker groups, the Arunthidiyar associations.
And increasingly it is with these organisations that the future lies.
INSIDE VIEW
The professionals at the heart of Network Theni explain programme has meant for them
JOHN DALTON- VST field officer
When I was a student I was a bit of an activist and
Network Theni's transition from service delivery to a
more rights-based approach has helped that activism to
return. It is really exciting and a privilege to be part of a
movement for social change. This has come about
through the impressive level of activism of the
federations and people's organisations. Federations have
influenced local government and taken action against
atrocities. TDNP+ (positive people's association) has
increased the visibility of HIV/Aids, influenced officials
and put HIV/Aids on the district agenda. Arundithiyars
have demonstrated en masse for the first time and have
confronted atrocity and untouchability head on.
Organisations of women in prostitution and
transgendered people have started to emerge. This has been a major challenge and a struggle but we have made
a start.
Another struggle has been to convince people that we should work with Dalits, not just because they are poor but because they are oppressed and marginalised. The other shift has been to realise that there are Dalits within the Dalits - the Arundithiyars. This process is by no means complete but Network Theni has a good record considering that none of the partner NGOs is Dalit-led.
There is no doubt that the work with village councils was some of the best of its kind in the state, and the only project I know of that had such a reach and presence in one district. It is really appropriate that we have attracted major funding to continue and further develop this work.
The project was able to make good use of the betterresourced primary health centres and the new voluntary HIV counselling and testing centres and the new antiretroviral unit. We can now see a way of devolving our medical programmes onto them. It is wonderful to be able to offer something really concrete to positive people in the way of life-giving treatment.
HIV/Aids has been something of a personal cause for me, and Network Theni gave me a good opportunity to learn more and to share experiences. We now have real evidence that people are changing their behaviour and it is very encouraging to know that we are saving lives.
At the same time, Network Theni has not been easy; networks never are. We have all invested plenty of time and effort - volunteers, people's organisations, federa-tions, NGOs, VST, field staff, administrators, accoun-tants. My overall feeling is this - we have started to get something moving and now the time is ripe - for yet more work!
VANAJAA - director of DACT
Networking! It's really difficult. Different visions, different
working knowledge, different mindsets. But we've done
some wonderful works. We created a model for others by
showing that we can work together to achieve our goals
even though we were not always united in our thinking.
All our partners but one are headed by men. But we all
worked together for women's empowerment and towards
gender equality. After many arguments gender equality has
been accepted by all our partners who all adopted gender
policies and made gender action plans. But there's still a long way to go especially on changing attitudes and making the changes endure.
The project equally concentrated on men with the idea that men have to to be part of the process of empowering women. Development cannot be achieved only by women; it needs men's support. Women and men need to work together to achieve our goal. So some supportive men were identified by the field workers and these men were trained on personality development and gender sensitisation. This yielded good results.
Empowerment of women is the key area for Network Theni and it started on this right from the beginning. Tremendous changes could be seen in the villages.
Some examples are
- Women started saying no to violence
- Women started asking questions in public
- Women showed they can work together and achieve things
The project created thousands of women entrepreneurs - some small, some big. This is a great change. Psychologically Woman is empowered when handling money. Money is power! And just because of this Man started respecting women. No wonder that our project led lots of women to improve their status, improve their knowledge and change their attitudes. I could write pages about the changes.
We too learnt a lot. At first we thought the government could not do anything and did not have the mindset to try. But after two years we changed our approach. Instead of regarding government as our foe we became friends - joining hands and sharing resources, helping them to cover more people on the medical side.
TNDP+ helped the public to remove their fears on HIV/Aids, helped them to change their attitudes, and the public got to know that if they didn't care about or give proper care to people living with HIV/Aids, then the positive people's association would respond. Even if this is not so sound as a technique, it yielded good results!
JOTHIRAMALINGAM - chair of
Development Action Consortium Trust, which
managed Network Theni
One of the outstanding achievements of Network Theni
is capacity building of stakeholders that participated in
this unique project. The strong professional central team
provided inputs in health and enterprise development to
partners and federations which enabled them to
strengthen and sustain the activities for long term impact.
poorer women and Dalits - the project helped reduce social and economic disparities. Successive evaluations showed how hundreds of women improved their wellbeing after joining self-help groups. This substantially improved their status in the family and in the community. The project played a significant role in making people aware their responsibilities in Panchayat Raj, the roles available through this governance system and the way in which local people can shape how the Panchayat operates. Thus the women have been empowered politically and they are a force to reckon with. The political parties now have to woo the groups by promising special schemes even to win state elections.
The plethora of people's organisations promoted through partner NGOs are becoming independent and gained an identity of their own. Work with people living with HIV/Aids has led not only to increased demands and services but to an increased ability of PLWHAs to speak in public. Aravanis (transsexuals and transgender people) have experienced increasing levels of empowerment.
Network Theni helped partners develop gender sensitive policies and gender action plans. It demonstrated how local organisations can work together to pool resources and expertise and avoid duplication of efforts.
Achievements notwithstanding, the network had its problems such as loss of autonomy felt by some partners and fear of domination by major players leading to lack of enthusiasm by some. Despite these problems, the transparency and openness of Network Theni permeated at all levels which fostered mutual trust and co-operation.
NETWORK THENI HAS A BIG FUTURE IN STORE
So has Network Theni finished? Well only in the sense that we planned a programme lasting five years with funding from the Big Lottery and those five years are now up. But in every other sense Network Theni has a big future. The plan was always to create lasting structures to combat discrimination, ill-health and poverty. These structures are the people's organisations - self-help groups, federations and other associations - making full use of government services and the village council system. The people's organisations will need our support for some time yet before they can function independently. We have a five-point plan to do this.
- For the next five years we will work with the federations and other people's organisations to strengthen the Panchayat Raj programme of village councils that was begun under Network Theni. The Panchayats are a means to deliver services such as health, village facilities, education and welfare as well as an end in themselves in that they offer a way for the disadvantaged - women and Dalits - to gain political power. The Big Lottery Fund has agreed to fund this programme.
- We expect soon to start a new programme working with Dalit activist organisations to fight the castebased discrimination that pervades rural India. The Department for International Development have provisionally agreed to fund this.
- In co-operation with Target Tuberculosis we will work to improve the quality of TB work done by the government's primary health centres in Theni District.
- If we can secure funding, we will work with associations of people living with HIV/Aids, in particular promoting condom use, and engaging with high risk groups.
- Working with Development Action Consortium Trust, VST's principal partner NGO in India, we will ensure that the momentum of Network Theni is maintained, particularly the credit and microenterprise programme. This will be funded from the donations we receive from you - our supporters.
This organisation is so very different
By our new programmes manager, Ruth Whitbread
I haven't been involved with
VST for very long - just eight
months. I began in November
2005 and immediately focused
on following up our funding
applications to the Big Lottery
Fund, the Department for International
Development and
the Elton John AIDS Foundation.
For such a small organisation
there seemed to be a
huge amount going on in
India. But it wasn't until I
visited early this year that I
became fully aware of the
impact VST is making and was
able to give true meaning to
the words I had been reading
on the pages of applications
for funding, newsletters and
annual reports.
I met a newly formed group of people living with HIV/Aids near Dindigul. The group consisted of 20 or so young women and one man. All the women were widows, their husbands having died from Aids. Many had children who were HIV positive. All described the rejection they had experienced from their families and communities who blamed them for infecting their sons, their sense of isolation and their fears for the future. The one man in the group had come along with his wife. Both were HIV positive, the husband insisting that his wife had been infected through a visit to the hospital.
The meeting was tame at first and the women appeared resigned. It took a long time for them to feel sufficiently safe to express their true feelings. ‘If my husband were alive today, I'd kill him for what he has done to me and my child'.
Howls of laughter. Gone was the resignation, replaced, not by resentment and rage, but resilience, courage and an overriding sense of purpose. These people were going to make the most of the life they have and take steps to secure the best possible future.
To date, my VST is about the many thousands of people our partners work with every day. Women in self-help groups and federations. The Arunthidiyar woman sitting nervously but proudly as a ward member in a Panchayat meeting. The sad and deeply troubling visit to the widow of an Arunthidiyar man murdered for being ‘uppity' enough to challenge his ‘betters'. Women, again, working hard in small businesses to improve the prospects for their families. And the husbands of those women, on the road to being ‘gender sensitised men' in an innovative programme encouraging them to seek harmony in the home through co-operation and sharing family responsibilities.
I have worked in development organisations before. For Oxfam for close to 10 years, Sightsavers International and as a VSO in Bangalore for two years. VST is very different and effective chiefly because of its close relationship with the community it works with. VST responds to the needs of poor and marginalised people with rare consistency and expertise developed over many years.
My VST is also about communicating the work to existing and potential supporters here in the UK. The Big Lottery Fund application for work with Panchayat Raj Institutions was successful and we will soon hear the outcomes of the DFID and Elton John applications.
After eight short months, I already feel a strong commitment to VST and hope to strengthen and deepen that commitment over the coming years.
THE SUPPORTERS LUNCH
Jothiramalingam, chair of Development Action Consortium Trust, and Vijayrani from Vasandham visited the UK in May. Sponsored by West Dene to visit projects chiefly in the West Country, they took time out of their busy schedule to come to our supporters lunch at the Rasa Maricham restaurant near Kings Cross on Saturday May 20th. We were also joined by John Dalton, secretary of Arogya Agam, who was on leave in the UK visiting friends and family.
Jothi, Vijayrani and John gave presentations about the work in India. John outlined plans for engagement with village level government - Panchayat Raj - and how this can bring about lasting change for poor and marginalised people. Vijayrani told us about her own work at Vasandham, the strength of the women's federation there and the strong ties to the community which build trust and ultimately provide a platform to address issues of injustice and discrimination. Jothi talked about the partnership that has characterised Network Theni and the challenges and achievements of working together.
Supporters were very pleased to have the opportunity to talk to our colleagues from India. “It brings the work to life and makes me feel much more involved and connected.”
And of course, everyone enjoyed the food and the chat. The atmosphere was relaxed and informal and the feedback very positive. Happily, thanks to the generous contributions from all our supporters, even those who could not attend, we raised some funds too. We would very much like to hold another supporters' day in the not too distant future, maybe changing the format slightly and perhaps even getting away from London for once!
DEVELOPMENT ACTION CONSORTIUM TRUST - NOW OUR PRINCIPAL PARTNER
Village Service Trust wanted to create a structure in India that would eventually co-ordinate all its activities within India. DAC trust was set up with directors of Network Theni partner organisations acting as trustees and VST's representative as chair. Over time the trust has become an open body with all trustees drawn from outside with VST representative acting as an adviser.
SR Jothiramalingam Chair and one of the founding members. Having served government and voluntary organisations for 15 years, he is leading Crusade, an NGO he set up in northern Tamil Nadu for poverty reduction and social advancement of the poor and marginalised. He was project adviser to VST for 12 years till 2004.
Bimla Chandrasekhar Founding member of DACT and founder of EKTA, a resource centre for women in Madurai. She is involved in a number of networks and national movements for women's social and political empowerment.
T K Nathan has held senior positions in government, voluntary and national level training institutions. In his own words he is 'a techno-commercial entrepreneur interested in micro-enterprise'.
R Sundaresan has been associated with Gandhian institutions and NGOs since 1980. As freelance consultant, he undertakes monitoring, evaluation and impact assessments studies on behalf of NGOs in India and donor agencies abroad.
Dr A Shantha will join the trust shortly. She is head of information and communication sciences of Madurai Kamaraj University. She organised several international workshops on journalism and evaluated a mother and child care programme for Unicef.
R Vanajaa DACT Programme Director has a master's in social work and was co-ordinating water and sanitation work by DANIDA before joining us.